Name: Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 45 min
Total time: 1 h
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 1 9-inch pie crust, unbaked; 1/2 cup water; 1 1/2 oz unsweetened chocolate; 2/3 cup granulated sugar; 1/4 cup butter; 2 teaspoons vanilla extract; 1 cup all-purpose flour; 1 teaspoon baking powder; 1/2 teaspoon salt; 1/4 cup butter, softened; 3/4 cup granulated sugar; 1 large egg; 1/2 cup whole milk; 1 teaspoon vanilla extract; 1/2 cup pecans, chopped; Whipped cream, optional

Jump to Recipe· 4.8 from 36 reviews

If you’re looking for a dessert that brings a little colonial charm and a whole lot of flavor to your table, you’ve got to try my Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe. This pie isn’t just delicious—it’s a nostalgic blend of a rich chocolate layer nestled atop a tender cake, all baked in a buttery crust that just melts in your mouth. Trust me, once you make this, it’ll become a staple in your recipe box for cozy nights and special occasions alike. Stick around, because I’m going to share all the tips that make this recipe foolproof and downright irresistible!

🧡

Why This Recipe Works

Perfect Texture Combination: The contrast between the fudgy chocolate layer and the soft cake base gives each bite delightful complexity.
Simple, Classic Ingredients: No need for fancy or elusive ingredients—everything you need is probably already in your pantry.
Easy Assembly: This pie is layered, not complicated, making it approachable even on busy days.
Nutty Crunch: Chopped pecans on top add a touch of texture and depth, rounding out the flavor beautifully.

Colonial Innkeeper's Pie, chocolate pie recipes, vintage dessert recipes, nostalgic pie desserts, easy homemade pie recipes - A close-up view of a pecan pie in a clear glass pie dish showing one thick layer of golden-brown filling topped with many small pieces of pecans with a slightly shiny, textured surface. The crust edge is light golden and slightly crimped, visible around the pie. The pie is placed on a white marbled texture with a striped cloth underneath. photo taken with an iphone --ar 2:3 --v 7

Ingredients & Why They Work

This pie is a harmonious marriage of a luscious chocolate topping and a fluffy, vanilla-scented cake baked right in the pie shell. Choosing quality ingredients like unsweetened chocolate and fresh pecans really elevates the flavor without adding fuss.

Colonial Innkeeper's Pie, chocolate pie recipes, vintage dessert recipes, nostalgic pie desserts, easy homemade pie recipes - Flat lay of whole unsweetened chocolate pieces, chopped pecans, a stick of softened butter, granulated sugar crystals, a fresh large egg, a small glass of whole milk, vanilla beans and a rolled unbaked pie crust, beautifully arranged with a small pile of sifted all-purpose flour and a teaspoon of baking powder placed on a white marble surface, photo taken with an iphone --ar 2:3 --v 7

Pie crust: A sturdy yet flaky crust is essential to hold all those layers together without getting soggy.
Unsweetened chocolate: Using real unsweetened chocolate ensures your chocolate layer isn’t overly sweet and has rich depth.
Granulated sugar: Balances bitterness in the chocolate and sweetens the cake perfectly.
Butter: Adds moisture and richness to both chocolate and cake layers, plus contributes to tender texture.
Vanilla extract: A little vanilla brings out all the other flavors, making the pie smell heavenly.
All-purpose flour: Provides structure for the cake layer while keeping it tender.
Baking powder: The secret weapon that helps the cake rise nicely and stay light.
Salt: Just a pinch enhances flavor and balances sweetness.
Egg: Binds ingredients and gives the cake its soft, springy texture.
Whole milk: Adds moisture and helps create a smooth batter.
Pecans: Toasted or raw, they add crunch and a toasty nuttiness that pairs beautifully with chocolate.
Whipped cream (optional): A dollop of fresh whipped cream is my favorite finishing touch that adds lightness and a creamy contrast.

📝

Note: You’ll find the complete list of ingredients, along with their exact measurements, in the printable recipe card at the bottom of this post.

Tweak to Your Taste

The wonderful thing about the Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe is how open it is to your personal spin. Over the years, I’ve tried a few tweaks that make it feel just right for different occasions or cravings, and I encourage you to experiment too.

Add a hint of cinnamon or nutmeg: I find that a dash of warm spices blends beautifully with the chocolate and pecans, giving the pie a cozier vibe, especially in cooler months.
Swap pecans for walnuts or almonds: Depending on what you have on hand or prefer, you can switch the nuts and still get that great crunch.
Make it gluten-free: Use a gluten-free flour blend instead of all-purpose flour; just add a little xanthan gum for best structure.
For extra indulgence: Stir in mini chocolate chips into the cake batter—they melt in the oven and give surprise pockets of chocolate.

Step-by-Step: How I Make Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe

Step 1: Prep the Pie Crust with Love

First, preheat your oven to 350°F. Take your 9-inch pie crust, and carefully line it inside the pie plate. Don’t forget to fold the edges under and flute them nicely—it makes the pie look so pretty and gives the crust a sturdier edge to hold all that filling. Pop the crust into your fridge to chill while you get the filling ready. This little step helps prevent the bottom from getting soggy.

Step 2: Make the Silky Chocolate Layer

Bring half a cup of water to a boil in a medium saucepan, then remove from heat and stir in the unsweetened chocolate until melted completely. Next, add two-thirds cup granulated sugar and bring it back to a boil briefly—watch it carefully so it doesn’t scorch. Remove from heat again and stir in butter and vanilla. This little chocolate potion is what makes the pie feel so special.

Step 3: Whip up the Cake Batter

In a bowl, sift together flour, baking powder, and salt—that little sift makes the cake layer tender and airy. In a separate large bowl, cream softened butter with sugar until light and fluffy (I use an electric mixer—it saves time and effort). Beat in the egg, then alternately add the flour mixture and milk, ending with vanilla. You’ll want to fold this gently so you don’t overmix. Pour this batter right into the pie crust and smooth it out with a spatula.

Step 4: Layer and Bake to Perfection

Give your chocolate mixture one last stir and carefully pour it over the cake batter in the pie crust. Sprinkle chopped pecans evenly on top to add that signature crunch and nutty flavor. Bake for about 45 minutes or until a toothpick inserted near the center comes out clean. Let it cool completely before slicing so each layer sets beautifully.

💡

Pro Tips for Making Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe

Chill the Crust: Putting the pie crust in the fridge before baking keeps it from shrinking and ensures a flakier edge.
Watch the Chocolate Carefully: Heat the chocolate and sugar just until boiling; overheating can make it grainy.
Don’t Overmix the Batter: Stir gently when combining wet and dry ingredients to keep the cake tender.
Test for Doneness: Use a toothpick near the center—if it comes out clean, it’s perfect, even if the top looks slightly soft.

How to Serve Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe

Colonial Innkeeper's Pie, chocolate pie recipes, vintage dessert recipes, nostalgic pie desserts, easy homemade pie recipes - A pie with three clear layers is shown: the bottom is a dark brown crust, the middle is a thick, light yellow cake layer with soft texture, and the top is a crunchy, nutty layer with chopped pecans in brown and golden shades. A slice of the pie is placed on a white plate in the background, showing the same layers. The pie is inside a clear glass dish sitting on a striped cloth with a white marbled surface underneath. Photo taken with an iphone --ar 2:3 --v 7

Garnishes

I always serve this pie with a generous dollop of freshly whipped cream. The creaminess cuts through the rich chocolate and soft cake layers, making each bite light and luscious. Sometimes, I sprinkle a little extra chopped pecan or a light dusting of cocoa powder on top for an extra touch of flair.

Side Dishes

Pair it with a cup of warmly spiced chai or classic black coffee for the ultimate cozy dessert experience. If you’re serving this after dinner, a fresh fruit salad with citrus notes or a simple scoop of vanilla ice cream complements the pie beautifully without overwhelming it.

Creative Ways to Present

For holidays or special gatherings, try serving individual slices with a drizzle of caramel sauce or a sprinkle of edible gold dust on the whipped cream. I’ve also had fun offering mini “pie jars” where the layers are made in small mason jars for a cute handheld twist that guests adore.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Once your pie has cooled completely, cover it tightly with plastic wrap or foil and store it in the refrigerator. It keeps wonderfully for 3 to 4 days, and honestly, the flavors deepen and meld, making it even tastier the next day.

Freezing

I’ve frozen this pie successfully by wrapping it well in plastic wrap and then aluminum foil to prevent freezer burn. When you’re ready, thaw it overnight in the fridge and let it come to room temperature before serving to retain the best texture.

Reheating

If you want that fresh-baked warmth, I recommend reheating slices in a low oven (around 300°F) for 10-15 minutes. Avoid microwaving if you can—it can make the cake layer gummy. A little warm is all you need to bring back that just-baked feeling.

FAQs

Can I use a homemade pie crust for the Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe?

Absolutely! Homemade pie crust adds a wonderful personal touch, and as long as it’s sturdy enough to hold the batter and chocolate, your pie will taste fantastic. Just be sure to chill it well before adding the filling to avoid shrinkage.
What can I substitute if I don’t have pecans?

You can replace pecans with walnuts, almonds, or even hazelnuts—whatever nuts you prefer or have on hand. If you’re allergic to nuts, omit them and consider adding toasted coconut flakes for crunch instead.
Is it necessary to boil the chocolate mixture twice?

Boiling the water and sugar with the chocolate helps properly dissolve the sugar and blend flavors for that deep chocolate layer. Just be careful not to overboil, which can affect texture.
Can I make this pie ahead of time for a party?

Definitely! This pie actually benefits from some resting time as the layers meld. Bake it a day ahead, refrigerate, and serve chilled or at room temperature with whipped cream right before guests arrive.
How do I know when the pie is fully baked?

Insert a toothpick into the center; if it comes out clean or with just a few moist crumbs, you’re good to go. The top should be set but not hard.

Final Thoughts

This Colonial Innkeeper’s Pie Recipe holds a special place in my kitchen because it’s simple to prepare yet yields a multi-layered dessert that feels like a warm hug on a plate. It’s one of those rare recipes that impresses guests but is easy enough for weeknight baking. Give it a try—I can’t wait for you to discover how memorable and delicious this pie is. Once you taste it, I bet it’ll become a classic in your home, just as it has in mine.