Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe

If you’re anything like me, sometimes you just crave something that feels like dessert and a shake all rolled into one—enter this delightful Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe. It’s got this perfect balance of tangy lemon and creamy sweetness that instantly brightens up any afternoon or casual get-together. The best part? It’s as fun to make as it is to sip, so you get that little kitchen win along with a refreshing treat.

I first stumbled upon this Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe on a lazy summer day and, honestly, it’s become my go-to when I want a quick indulgence that doesn’t require a lot of fuss. Whether you’re throwing a casual hangout or just want to shake up your dessert routine, this shake brings that nostalgic lemon pie vibe in a glass—trust me, you’ll find yourself coming back for seconds.

this …

Ingredients & Why They Work

Each ingredient in this Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe plays a key role in nailing that perfect pie-in-a-glass vibe. Plus, they’re pretty accessible, making shopping simple and stress-free.

• Vanilla Ice Cream: Adds creamy richness and the perfect sweet base to balance lemon’s tartness.
• Instant Lemon Pudding Mix: The star for authentic lemon flavor and thick texture without extra effort.
• Milk: Helps blend the shake smoothly; use whichever type you prefer—dairy or nondairy.
• Golden Oreos: Give that buttery cookie crunch and decorate the glass for flair.
• Whipped Cream: For topping, it adds a light, fluffy finish that complements the tangy shake.
• Vanilla Buttercream (for the glass): Creates a delicious frosting rim that’s both tasty and helps the cookie crumbs stick.

Tweak to Your Taste

I love making this Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe my own depending on the mood or ingredients on hand—you’ll find that a little switch-up goes a long way in flavor and texture.

• Lemon Extract Boost: Adding a splash of lemon extract amps up the citrus zing; I like this when I want more punch without extra pudding mix.
• Different Cookies: Swap Golden Oreos for shortbread or graham crackers for a new twist—you might discover a new favorite pairing!
• Dairy Alternatives: I’ve tried almond and oat milk versions that taste just as dreamy if you’re looking for nondairy options.
• Frozen Yogurt Swap: For a lighter option, replacing ice cream with lemon or vanilla frozen yogurt gives a tangy twist that’s refreshing.

Step-by-Step: How I Make Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe

Step 1: Prep Your Glass with a Frosted Cookie Rim

Start by frosting the outside of your serving glass with vanilla buttercream—this sticky coating is the secret to getting those crushed cookies to cling perfectly. After that, crush two of your Golden Oreos until they’re fine crumbs, and gently roll the glass in them. This not only looks inviting but gives you that delicious cookie crunch with every sip—I’ve found this little step really elevates the whole experience.

Step 2: Blend the Shake

Add 1 ½ cups of vanilla ice cream, 3 tablespoons of instant lemon pudding mix, and ½ cup of milk into your blender. Blend everything together until smooth and velvety—usually around 30 seconds to a minute. Don’t over-blend or the milkshake will get too runny; I always pause and check the consistency before going a bit longer.

Step 3: Assemble and Garnish

Pour the shake into your prepared glass. Top generously with whipped cream, then place one whole Golden Oreo on top. This final touch adds a fun bit of texture and keeps the bright lemon theme going. My friends especially love curling up with their shakes this way—it feels like dessert, but in a glass that you can sip your way through.

How to Serve Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe

Garnishes

Personally, I keep it simple with a generous swirl of whipped cream and a single Golden Oreo perched on top. Sometimes I zest a little lemon peel over the whipped cream for an extra burst of citrus aroma—it’s a game-changer. Feeling fancy? A drizzle of lemon curd or a sprinkle of edible glitter adds a festive touch.

Side Dishes

This shake pairs beautifully with something light and crunchy like salty kettle chips or a simple fruit salad—something that contrasts the creamy sweetness. I’ve even served it alongside buttery shortbread cookies for an extra cookie party vibe. If it’s brunch time, a lemon poppyseed muffin holds the theme perfectly.

Creative Ways to Present

Once, for a summer birthday party, I served the shake in mini mason jars with striped paper straws and tied little lemon slices on the rim with twine. It made the shakes feel like a sparkling celebration in each glass. Layering the shake with crushed cookie crumbs inside the glass before pouring created a fun visual ‘pie crust’ effect—definitely a crowd-pleaser!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you happen to have any leftover milkshake (it happens!), store it in an airtight container in the fridge and give it a good stir before drinking. It won’t be quite as thick but still delicious. I usually drink leftovers within a day for best texture.

Freezing

I’ve experimented with freezing this shake in popsicle molds, and it’s a fun twist on the original. The flavor stays vibrant, though the texture becomes more solid like a frozen dessert. Just let a pop sit for a minute or two before eating for easier enjoyment.

Reheating

Reheating isn’t really recommended here since it’s meant to be cold and creamy, but if you find the frozen pops too hard, just leave them at room temperature for a little while instead of heating. This keeps the texture more enjoyable without turning it into a melted mess.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Lemon Pie Milkshake Recipe feels like a little joyful indulgence that brightens up your day with every sip. I adore how easy it is to whip up but still feels special enough for company or an everyday treat. If you want to bring some sunshine to your kitchen, give this recipe a try—you’ll love how it combines creamy, tangy, and crunchy elements in a glass. Pour one for yourself and celebrate the simple pleasures of life with this lovely shake!

Print